Bismika Alllahuma

回答的回教 张贴了早期 反应 在反对我们出版 韩Kung在先知Muhammad (p). 有几个问题在这反应由Jochen · Katz， 事实上 独裁者 回答的回教那需要改正。 我们简要地将反应每一指控，是：

• Jochen Katz在假设，似乎来太斋戒一个结论I (MENJ)有排斥控制 Bismika Allahuma’ s社论政策。 我们不知道怎么他跑事在他的网站，亦不我们关心对此. 应该这里陈述它从开始那 Bismika Allahuma 是关注几个回教人的网上合作 deen 并且看见站点的愿望促进他们的反驳对基督徒和反伊斯兰教的力量在互联网。 Bismika Allahuma 不由“MENJ的”名字旋转大约一个个体。 我们跑事这里在依照到a shura’回教咨询。 这是 没有 我的个人站点，可以访问 这里. Katz需要停止强加他的纳粹遗产给我们在视同 Bismika Allahuma 与“MENJ”和“MENJ”与 Bismika Allahuma as，除为事实之外我的确共同了创办这个站点与伙伴，这个项目不是我自己，并且我不采取专横控制过度它，不同于怎样Katz也许假设专横掌握 他的 站点。
• Jochen Katz采取问题以一个简单的句子： “关于先知Muhammad (p)”的基督徒观点。 我们从未说Kung的观点代表 所有 基督徒或那他的词是所有基督徒必须跟随的单一标准当局。 Katz一定太多是读书入文本。 再次，怎样事跑在 Bismika Allahuma 是完全与怎样不同Katz以他的专政跑事在他的网站。 然而，满足Katz的自我和表明我们的解释，我们有 重说了文本. 我们希望Katz不再将有所有怨言关于怎样句子措辞了。
• Since Katz seems to have wasted his (and our) time complaining about such a minor issue about whether Kung is speaking on behalf of “THE Christian” community or one of the various diverse Christian opinions, we will not be bothered about the rest of his polemical diatribe. As usual, Katz loves to split hairs and as a testament to his undying hatred of the Prophet Muhammad (P), tries to cast doubt on the scholarly credentials of Hans Kung. Now, we know who Hans Kung is, and he is a well-known authority who is often invited to speak at universities in the Muslim World. Now who is one obscure (Nazi!) German mathematician by the name of “Jochen Katz” is, compared to the world-renowned Catholic theologian¹ by the name of Hans Kung?
• Lastly, Katz decides to beat a dead horse by preaching about the so-called “falsehood” of the Prophet Muhammad (P). Since Katz was so hung up about Kung’s glowing tribute to the Prophet Muhammad (P) and questioned Kung’s “representation” of the Christian community², may we be justified in saying that Katz’s opinion is only one opinion and does not represent ALL Christians in their opinion of the Prophet (P)?

With this brief assessment, we end our response here. And only Allah knows best!

The author is the co-founder and executive editor of Bismika Allahuma. His personal blog may be accessed at www.menj.org

1. We believe that Katz has been making up stories in his polemic about the “non-Catholicity” of Hans Kung, as to the best our knowledge, Kung is still a Catholic priest and is introduced as such in every lecture he attends. According to his Wikipedia entry: “He [Kung] was not excommunicated and remains a Roman Catholic priest.” [back]
2. Although we have never stated that this is so! [back]