If you're new here, you may want to get regular updates via如果你是新这里,你可能想通过定期更新 RSS feed RSS提要 . Thank you for visiting!谢谢您的访问!

Mohd Elfie Nieshaem Juferi莫哈末Elfie Nieshaem Juferi

From the beginning of Orientalism, the Christian missionaries have been assuming that Islam is “headless” enough to be attacked and scrutinized with a ferocity that one can only conclude borders on fanaticism.从东方开始,基督教传教士已经假定,伊斯兰教是“无头”足以成为一个凶猛的攻击,并只能得出一个结论,一个狂热的边界上审议。 These missionaries proved then that they do not have the brains to acknowledge their own headlessness.这些传教士证明这时,他们的大脑没有承认自己的无核心。 One such example is其中一个例子是 David Wood大卫伍德 , a recent zealous recruit by the ever-intolerent Answering Islam , whose only amazing ability is his extreme belligerence, and what can only be described as fanatical intolerence, towards a faith different from his. ,最近,什么招聘热心由不断intolerent 回答伊斯兰教 ,他们的唯一惊人的能力是他极端好战,只能说是狂热的耐力,对他的信仰不同。 This is a review of one such这是一个这样的检讨 article文章 .

Mr. Wood begins by saying:伍德先生首先说:

    Muhammad穆罕默德 's empire of faith has managed to thrive in the modern world for one simple reason: Muslims have kept Muhammad?s dark past a secret.对信仰的帝国却可以在现代世界蓬勃发展的一个简单的原因:穆斯林一直穆罕默德?的过去黑暗的秘密。 Indeed, they have gone beyond keeping it a secret; they have somehow convinced themselves (and many others) that Muhammad was an outstanding moral example, perhaps even the greatest moral example of all time.事实上,他们已超越保持这个秘密,他们相信自己有某种(和许多其他的),穆罕默德是一位杰出的道德榜样,甚至是有史以来最伟大的道德榜样。 Perpetuating this fraud has been, in my opinion, the most stupendous deception in world延续这种欺诈行为已经,在我看来,在世界上最庞大的诈骗 history历史 .

We are sure that it has been such “a very large secret” that the incidents “exposed” in Mr. Wood's belligerent piece were actually recorded in some recent contemporary biographies of the Prophet Muhammad (P).我们相信,它已被这样的“一个非常大的秘密”,该事件“暴露”在伍德先生的好战一块,实际上在一些先知穆罕默德(规划)最近当代传记记录。 Mr. Wood should consider reading the late Martin Ling's “伍德先生应考虑读已故马丁灵的“ Muhammad: His Life Based on the Earliest Sources 穆罕默德:他的生活来源的基础上,最早 “, MH Haykal's “ “先生,MH Haykal的” The Life of Muhammad 穆罕默德生命 ” and another book, “ The Sealed Nectar ” and see whether these eminent writers have concealed even a fraction of the Prophet's (P) life. “和一本新书,” 密封蜜源 “,看看是否这些杰出的作家,隐匿甚至一小部分生活的先知(规划)。

Yet Mr. Wood continue to persist in this mindless bigotry, and says:但伍德先生继续坚持这种不用动脑筋的偏见,并说:

    The difficulty here is that, no matter how loudly a Muslim shouts these objections, they have no power to overcome the historical fact that Muhammad was a robber and a murderer.这里的困难是,无论怎样大声穆斯林条留言这些反对意见,他们没有权力来克服的历史事实,穆罕默德是一个强盗和杀人犯。

One should not throw stones at glass houses, and similarly one could say the following for the Judeo-Christian faith:人们不应扔在玻璃房子里的石头,同样可以说为犹太教和基督教信仰如下:

    The difficulty here is that, no matter how loudly a Jew/Christian shouts these objections, they have no power to overcome the historical fact that Moses was a robber and a murderer. 这里的困难是,无论怎样大声犹太人/基督教条留言这些反对意见,他们没有权力来克服的历史事实,摩西是一个强盗和杀人犯。

Mr. Wood has not proven anything apart from an assertion that, in his view, what the Prophet (P) did was “robbing and murdering”.伍德先生还没有证明任何东西,除了一个断言,在他看来,什么先知(规划)所做的“抢劫杀人”。

The following are some of the claims that he has charged against the Prophet (P).以下是他已对先知(规划)收取的一些要求。 Do note the nature of the polemical trend employed by Mr Wood.是否注意到了伍德先生聘请的论战趋势的性质。 They are neither “new” nor have they not been discussed or answered aeons ago.他们既不是“新”也没有,他们没有讨论或回答aeons前。 What we will do here is to reproduce some of the charges, and provide a link to a further discussion on the issue.我们将在这里做什么是复制部分收费,并提供一个就这一问题进一步讨论环节。 This is to demonstrate to Mr. Wood and his missionary pals that their tired, old repetitions are not unfamiliar to us, and to send a message that we are not interested in reinventing the wheel and waste our time in responding .这是为了表明伍德先生和他的伙伴们对我们的传教士,他们累了,老重复并不陌生,并派出一个响应消息, 我们不感兴趣的重复劳动和时间浪费

The following are some of the claims that were made.以下是已经作出的一些要求。

Claim #1: When Muhammad began receiving his revelations, his first impression was that he was possessed by demons 索赔#1:当穆罕默德开始接受他的启示,他的第一印象是,他是魔鬼附体

This was discussed by Al-Nowaihi, who这是讨论由Al - Nowaihi,谁 notes笔记 that:说:

It is important to realize that when that search culminated in his hearing the voice of Gabriel in Mount Hira, at the age of forty, he did not hasten to believe in his revelation or become convinced of it overnight.重要的是要意识到,当该搜索最终导致他的听力在40岁的加布里埃尔希拉山的声音,他不急于相信他的启示,或因它深信过夜。 He passed through a period of considerable doubt and fear, terrified lest it be only the wicked trick and cruel jesting of Satan, and he needed the wholehearted support of his faithful wife Khadija to overcome his fears. I venture to suggest that this was an attestation of his integrity; a deliberate impostor bent upon deception would not have gone through those agonizing terrors. Furthermore, a careful reading of the early suras of the Qur'?shows that, even after he was convinced of the authenticity of his revelation, it was only with great reluctance that he accepted the awesome burden of his mission, and only after he was driven by an overpowering sense of the duty which he could not shirk.他经历了一个相当时期的恐惧和怀疑,发音,以免它只能欺骗和邪恶撒旦残酷开玩笑,他需要的妻子卡蒂嘉全力支持他的忠实克服自己的恐惧。 我敢说,这是一个认证他的正直,一个弯后,蓄意欺骗骗子不会有恐怖经历的痛苦。此外,他是认真的启示,阅读早期suras的古兰经'?表明,即使是之后相信他的真实性只有极不情愿,他接受了他的使命真棒负担,只是在他是由他的责任不能推卸压倒感的驱使。

(For more on the Christian missionary abuse of the Fatrah incident, see (欲了解更多有关基督教的Fatrah事件,传教士滥用见 The Fatrah: Intermission of the Prophet Muhammad 该Fatrah:先知穆罕默德的间歇 )

Claim #2: Muhammad supported his fledgling religion by robbing people 索赔#2:穆罕默德掠夺人民支持他的羽翼未丰的宗教

(For more on the legislation and beginning of jihad, see (有关的立法和圣战的开始,见 The Legislation and the Beginning of Jihad立法和圣战开始 )

Claim #3: Muhammad was often ruthless towards his adversaries 索赔#3:穆罕默德对他的对手往往无情

On the contrary, the Prophet (P) was always gentle and treated his enemies kindly, and this is a fact recognised by the most virulent of his contemporary enemies.相反,先知(规划)总是温柔和善意对待他的敌人,这是由他的当代最恶毒的敌人所公认的事实。

(For more refutations to accusations of the so-called “brutality” of the Prophet (P), see如需驳斥对所谓的“野蛮的先知(规划),”指控(见 What About The Killing of Ka'ab bin Al-Ashraf? 怎么样斌杀伤Ka'ab铝阿什拉夫? and The Killing of Abu 'Afak and Asma' bint Marwan? 阿布的马尔万杀'阿费克和Asma'宾特? )

Claim #4: Muhammad had far more wives than even his own revelations allowed 索赔#4:穆罕默德拥有了自己的启示,甚至可以远远超过他的妻子

This is a false claim, as the injunction on the limitation of wives does not apply to the Prophet's (P) wives.这是一个虚假的索赔,作为对妻子的限制禁令并不适用于先知的(P)的妻子。 As they had attained a high stature in the Muslim community of believers ( Ummul Mukminin or “Mothers of the Believers), it would be nothing short of an injustice to deprive them of their status by divorcing them and hence condemn them to humiliation.当他们达到了一个信徒)高身材穆斯林社会对信徒(Ummul Mukminin或“母亲的,这将是短暂的任何不公正剥夺的地位对他们的离婚,因此他们谴责他们的侮辱。 For the Prophet's (P) marriages, a separate law was given to him, namely that he may not marry any more women after this revelation was revealed.对于先知(P)的婚姻,一个独立的法律给予了他,那就是他可能没有任何结婚后,这个启示更多的妇女被揭露。

(For more on the Prophet Muhammad's wives, see (欲了解更多有关先知穆罕默德的妻子,见 Why Was The Prophet Polygamous? 为什么是先知一夫多妻? )

Claim #5: Muhammad consummated a marriage to a nine-year-old girl 索赔#5:穆罕默德完善婚姻到9岁的小女孩

(For more on Muhammad's relationship with Aisha, see (欲了解更多有关穆罕默德与艾莎的关系,见 The Young Marriage of Aishah 青年结婚的Aishah )

Claim #6: Muhammad had a contemptible opinion of women 索赔#6:穆罕默德有妇女卑鄙的意见

(For more on the Islamic view of women, see (欲了解更多关于妇女伊斯兰的观点,见 The Position of Women in Islam 在伊斯兰教的妇女地位 )

Claim #7: Muhammad is unique among prophets in that he is the only one to receive a revelation, proclaim it as part of God's message to man, and later take it back, claiming that it was actually from Satan. 索赔#7:穆罕默德是先知中独一无二的,他是唯一一个得到一个启示,宣告它的人作为上帝的信息的一部分,后来把它收回,并声称这是真正从撒旦。

(For more on the Orientalist fantasy regarding this unauthentic tradition, see (欲了解更多有关这方面的东方幻想非真实的传统,见 Those Are Their High-Flying Lies Indeed 这些都是他们自己在高空飞行的谎言的确 )

Hence from these mere selective “claims”, Mr Wood tries to conclude that:因此,从这些仅仅是有选择性的“索赔”,伍德先生试图得出这样的结论:

    These are just some of the facts that Muslims have been keeping secret, but they are enough to make any reasonable person doubt the validity of Islam.这些仅仅是事实,穆斯林一直保持秘密,但他们都足以使任何合理怀疑的人对伊斯兰教的有效性。

On the contrary, the allegations that were hurled and repeated ad nauseam by the missionary is nothing new.相反,被指控的传教士投掷不厌其烦的和重复的广告是新事物。 They have been discussed, debated, and refuted by Muslim and non-Muslim scholars time and time again.他们进行了讨论,辩论,以及穆斯林和非穆斯林学者的时间和时间再次驳斥。 Mr. Wood is perhaps ignorant of the copious amount of material on these issues and who can blame him?伍德先生,也许是物质丰富金额无知就这些问题,谁又能责怪他呢? Perhaps he has been living in a mono-culture all his life and has never come across a single Muslim on the street.也许他一直生活在一个单一文化的所有他的生活,从未出现过一个穆斯林在街上。

    The truth about Muhammad has been one of the world's best-kept secrets.关于穆罕默德一直是世界上最神秘的地方之一真理。 For centuries, it has been virtually impossible to raise objections about the character of Muhammad in Muslim countries, for anyone who raised such objections would (following the example set by Muhammad himself) immediately be killed.几个世纪以来,它已经几乎不可能提高对穆罕默德在穆斯林国家的性质,任何人的反对意见,谁提出了这样的反对意见会(以下由穆罕默德亲自树立的榜样)立即被杀死。

And it was possible to raise issues of doubt about the character of Jesus (P) in the Spanish Inquisition and Crusades era, for example?并有可能提高对耶稣(P)的西班牙宗教裁判所和十字军东征时代特征疑问的问题,例如? Mr. Wood is trying to “pull wool” over his reader's eyes, without a doubt.伍德先生是想“拉过他的读者的眼睛羊毛”,毫无疑问。

We will not make secret of the fact that reviewing Mr. Wood's article (not to mention我们不会让秘密的事实,回顾Wood先生的文章(不提 his series他的系列 of Christian belligerent nonsense) has been nothing but a most tiresome exercise.基督教的好战废话),但一直没有一个最烦人的工作。 Mr. Wood tries to cast the illusion as though “criticism” of the Prophet (P) is something foreign or alien to the Muslim world.伍德先生试图投仿佛“的批评,先知(规划)”的幻想是外国或外来的东西向穆斯林世界。 On the contrary, attacking Islam has been as old as the founding of Islam itself and “criticism” of the Prophet (P) as old as Orientalism itself.相反,攻击伊斯兰教已被作为伊斯兰教本身与“批判的先知(P)的”东方学本身一样古老建国的历史。

We also demand evidence from Mr. Wood about his claim that “anyone who raised such objections would…immediately be killed” .我们还要求伍德先生对他的证据,声称“任何人提出打死谁”,这种反对立即将...。 What is the proof of his sweeping statement?什么是他武断的证明? In which countries are these people killed for their “criticism” and what is the nature of their so-called “criticism”?在哪些国家是他们的“批评”杀死这些人,什么是他们所谓的“批评”的性质?

Yet Mr. Wood continues with:但伍德先生继续为:

    In the end, Islam will fall, for the entire structure is built upon the belief that Muhammad was the greatest moral example in history, and this belief is demonstrably false.最后,伊斯兰教将下降为整体结构,是建立在相信穆罕默德是历史上最伟大的道德典范,这显然是错误的信念建立。

Unfortunately for Mr. Wood, Islam does not rise or fall on a single individual.伍德先生不幸的是,伊斯兰教不上升或下降的一个人。 It is true that the Prophet Muhammad is held in the highest esteem.诚然,先知穆罕默德是在最高推崇。 It is actually more true to say the following about它实际上是更真实地说以下有关 Christianity基督教 :

    In the end, Christianity will fall, for the entire structure is built upon the belief that Jesus was the God-incarnate, and this belief is demonstrably false. 最后,基督教将下降结构,整个是假的建立在相信耶稣是神的化身,而这种想法明显。

Indeed, countless individuals and groups have secretly wished for Islam's downfall from past to present.事实上,无数个人和团体都希望从过去的秘密为伊斯兰教的垮台至今。 However, we are not disturbed by the secret desires of Mr. Wood and his belligerent Christian missionary pals to see Islam's destruction.不过,我们不会受伍德先生和他的好战的基督教传教士好朋友的秘密渴望看到伊斯兰教的破坏。 There is no reason to believe that Mr. Wood and his pals will succeed where their more “knowledgeable” predecessors in the likes of Margoliuth, Muir, Zwemmer and Pfander had failed before.我们没有理由相信伍德先生和他的伙伴们将接替在那里他们更多的“知识”在Margoliuth,缪尔,Zwemmer和普凡德尔喜欢前人没有过。

And with that, we say that only God knows best!有了这样的,我们说,只有上帝知道最好的! bismika tombstone Wood Chopped Down: The Information Superhighway and the Nonsense of Christian Missionary Belligerency

  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • del.icio.us
  • MySpace
  • Live
  • NewsVine
  • Propeller
  • Reddit
  • BlinkList
  • Sphinn
  • StumbleUpon
  • SphereIt
  • Technorati
  • Tumblr
  • Fark
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Posterous
  • Twitter
  1. islamispeace says: islamispeace 说:

    Your whole premise, my dear Philip, is absurd.你的整个前提下,我亲爱的菲利普,是荒谬的。 You made a comment here criticizing the author of this article for using certain words to refer to the missionary David Wood, when what you should have done, if you wanted to be taken seriously, was distance yourself from Wood's comments.您在这里作出评论批评这种使用某些词汇来指传教士大卫伍德,当你应该做的,如果你想认真对待文章的作者,是距离伍德的评论自己。 You will notice that in my initial response to you, I did not refer to Jesus_follower specifically (except when referring to the administrator's comments) but to Christians who use insulting ways to preach to Muslims.你会发现,在我最初的反应你的,我没有提到Jesus_follower除非特别提到管理员的评论(),但基督徒谁使用侮辱性的方式来宣扬穆斯林。 You have refused to distance yourself from these missionaries (are they following the Biblical way of preaching??).您已拒绝从这些传教士距离自己(他们按照圣经的说教方式?)。 That is enough for me to conclude that you are not interested in dialog and discussion.这是足以让我断定你是不是在对话和讨论的兴趣。

  2. Ashar Ashar says: 说:

    I am working with a christian missionary organization since last 10 years.我正与一个基督徒,因为过去10年传教组织。 I have never felt for a single moment that i should consider this eligion as a true religion.我从来没有感受到一刻,我应该考虑作为一个真正的宗教这个eligion。 I am Muslim, but after joining this organization, thanks to Allah, that my beleif on Islam has become firm.我是穆斯林,但在加入这个组织,感谢真主,我对伊斯兰教的信仰,已成为坚定的。 Jesus says, if some one slaps on your one cheak, turn the other towards him to slap on that as well, if some one takes your coat from you, offer him the shirt too.耶稣说,如果有人在你的一绰掴,打开,作为好,如果有人从你你的外衣,给他的衬衫等,以向他掴了。 I ask, if i go to any christians house and kidnape his doughter for sex, will he follow me with his other doughter to offer????????我想问,如果我去任何基督徒的房子和他的性别doughter kidnape,他将跟随他的其他doughter我提出???????? never possible coz its against nature of man.没有可能的表兄弟姐妹的反对人类的本质。 So, christianity for me, is totally against nature所以,对我来说基督教,是完全违反自然

  3. P. Spencer says: 体育斯潘塞 说:

    That, my friend, is not my point.这,我的朋友,是不是我的观点。 While I cannot speak directly for Mr. Wood, I am horribly 'offended' (how loosely do we use that term ;) ) that you would put all Christians under an umbrella like the author has done here.虽然我不能直接伍德先生发言,我感到可怕的'得罪'(松散的,我们如何使用这个词;)),您将置于一个像笔者伞在这里做了所有的基督徒。 To clarify, you just said that if I wanted to be taken sincerely I would have to distance myself from Mr. Wood's comments… excuse me if I'm wrong, but if I'm here to 'defend' Mr. Wood, why would I distance myself from him?为了澄清,你刚才说,如果我想采取真诚,我会保持距离的Wood先生的评论我自己...原谅我,如果我错了,但如果我在这里'捍卫'Wood先生,为什么会我距离他自己?

    As to Ashar's comment, I would gladly agree.至于Ashar的评论,我会很高兴地同意。 Christianity is different and against human nature.基督教是不同的,反人性。 The very idea that God would love totally depraved creatures so much that He would take on their likeness, and die in one of the worst ways ever known to man to save them, is totally unique.这种想法,上帝会爱完全堕落的动物这么多,他会接受他们的肖像,并死在有史以来人类已知的最严重的,以拯救他们的方法之一,是完全独一无二的。 That's part of what sets Christianity apart from every single religion on earth, including Islam.这部分与台基督教除了地球上的每一单一宗教,包括伊斯兰教。 As to your premise, that is absolutely out of context.至于你的前提,这是绝对断章取义。 The Bible also has laws for things like that.圣经也对这样的事情的法律。 Try reading the Old Testament for starters.尝试对初学者阅读旧约。

    In Christ, Philip在基督里,菲利普

    Leave a Reply留下一个回复

    You must be你必须 logged in登录 to post a comment.张贴评论。