Trinitarian Ontology ?

:

15- 2006

��������� ���� ����� �� ����������� ����� ����������� ���� �����

, RSS. !

Imran Aijaz

theism, , philosophers . theistic philosophers , Plantinga, Swinburne, Craig William, .

Swinburne, , theistic , , toto. . -, -talk' ` , a priori theistic . 1 , . 2Finally, Swinburne particularism, , , etc.3 epitomizes evidentialist Lockean, .

, philosophers evidentialist Swinburne. epistemologists, spearheaded Plantinga Wolterstorff, theistic , evidentialist grounds.4 , , theism .

prefatory , tenability () , philosophers. ontology, monotheism ` ontologically . particularism ( ontology ), , a priori , , a fortiori, doctrinal ontology .

philosophers ontology , , .

, presuppositions, . Terminus , giver', ` cause', ` designer', ` . Theist, , . Swinburne, :

« (.. ), , sustainer , , (.. omnipotent), , , , , , , , . » 5

- theism , theism. ontology , monotheistic : , Sustainer . , . a priori ( Swinburne) , ( ).

: Swinburne , explicated theism, ? a priori , ? , ?

Trinitarian Ontology

, Swinburne, tri-. , 3 (, ) , / . , Athanasian , :

«[T] , . , . , , . Godhead , , , Co-Eternal. , , , , . / 3 , , 3 ; , 3 ; , 3 , . » 6

, Cartwright7 7 , , .

    1. .
    2. .
    3. .
    4. .
    5. .
    6. .
    7. .

onwards, , Athanasian .

Tri- ?

ontological . a priori a posteriori . a priori , . , . . , , . a priori , .

a posteriori , . , , - , . , , . , .

, , (1) - (7) . 2 , , theism, . , a posteriori ( ) .

x, y, Z. , Swinburne, G. Cartwright, ` ` with'8, , x = g, y = g, z = G. , ( Leibniz , : x , y x y ) x = y, x = z, y = Z. , : (4) - (6). , Sprit .

g term9 . , x g, y g z G. (7), 3 , tri-theism. Cartwright syllogism: « ; 3 ; , 3 ». 10 : a, b B a. Cartwright . , .

: x, y z g, , 3 . modalism , , , . x, y z g (.. genera), 3 , : tri-theism. , (4) - (6). , (7). , (1) - (7) . facto ipso , , .

Particularism

ontology, Athanasian , . ontology . ontological incoherence doctrinal . , divinity ( ), ( ), etc. , a priori doctrinal .

, Athanasian ontologically . , . , tri-theism. , , , . theism Swinburne Craig, , , monotheism ` - - . ���������� ����� bismika Trinitarian Ontology �����������?

  1. . Swinburne Theism (, Clarendon: 1977) []
  2. Swinburne, (, Clarendon: 1991) []
  3. Swinburne (, Clarendon: 1989), (, Clarendon: 1992). []
  4. . , Plantinga & Wolterstorff, ( , : 1983) []
  5. Swinburne, Theism, P. 1 []
  6. Athanasian , -. , . []
  7. Cartwright , ` Trinity', ( MIT: 1987), P. 188. []
  8. Cartwright, , P. 191 []
  9. Ibid., P. 192 []
  10. Ibid., P. 196 []
  • �������� � ���������
  • BlinkList
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Bookmarks Google
  • LinkedIn
  • � �������� ������� �������
  • MySpace
  • NewsVine
  • ���������
  • Reddit
  • SphereIt
  • Sphinn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter
  • Yahoo! ��������

:

,
  1. :
    4- 2006 3:32 am

    , 3 , 4, 5, 6. , (, Fater, , , , , , ,)

  2. Denis Giron :
    26- 2006 4:24 pm

    -, «» MENJ Imran Aijaz. - , , Imran brillian Muslims .

    15- , (.. ) :

    « g = x, g = z, g = y, g = (x + y + z), .»

    Imran. Imran Godhead . Imran .

    Imran William Craig (cf. , « Worldview "). 3 , . « ,» copula interpretated (.. , [Abraham]). , 1: 1. , ( ) , , , .

    weill i :

    G'x x «» (.. )
    Godhead.

    Gx ( vocalized G---x G--x, ) - , namely x .

    f, j, h, ixGx , , Godhead, ( ixGx, Leftow Russell , , ixGx g).

    x - > y « x, y»,

    ~ ( ~x not-x)

    =

    &

    x y biconditional (.. x y , , y x),

    x.P.y x y

    {x, y, z} / x, y z

    x.U.y x y Godhead

    (x) (.. x)

    (Ex) (.. x, x )

    , :

    1. (x) (Gx (x = ixGx))
    2. ~ (Ex) (Gx & ~ (x = ixGx))
    3. (x) (G'x - > x.P.ixGx)
    4. (x) (y) ((x.P.ixGx & y.P.ixGx) - > x.U.y)
    5. G'f
    6. G'j
    7. G'h
    8. ~Gf
    9. ~Gj
    10. ~Gh
    11. (~ (f = j) & ~ (f = h)) & ~ (j = h)
    12. {f, j, h} = ixGx

    : - Godhead , Godhead. , 2 Monotheism ( , Godhead). (.. ) Godhead ( consequent th Godhead «» ). 2 ( ) Godhead Godhead. *how* ; . , , , . , , , ( ) Godhead. 3 . Godhead - 3 toto. - . *can* toto, . (.. ).

  3. meedge :
    3- 2006 6:27 pm

    :

    « , .»

    . ?

    ? ? ( ) . . , . . ?

    , :
    «, , - ?»

    ? ? , . , , . -, . .

    .
    « x, y, Z. , Swinburne, G. Cartwright, ` ` with'8, , x = g, y = g, z = G. , ( Leibniz , : x , y x y ) x = y, x = z, y = Z. , : (4) - (6). , Sprit .»

    - / completely different / ? . ? .

    , - wholey, . infer - - wholely wholey . . _beyond_ , .

  4. shery :
    13- 2006 12:53 am

    : , « ?» Randel , Marcan Matthean, : jesus, jesus, « : , » (3:21 ), Mary , ?

    theist, , : , . ( ?) , ( -, figments ), . , , ( ).

    , , ( ). : 1. , . 2. . .., , , godhead, « » . , , , ? BTW, , ( ), , -, , . ? ? . , .

1 2 3

.