キリスト教のPolemicistsの同性愛そして無学の一致


2007年9月18日

キリスト教の宣教師および無神論者の最も笑えるような議論間にある 議論 イスラム教が同性愛を禁止しないこと、そしてそれがイスラム教で許されていることを示すため。 これは無知および無能力がいかにの人を彼の反対者の前に冗談にならせることができるか全く理想的な例である。 これらのタイプの人々のイスラム教の無学を払いのけるためには、私達はその同性愛を全く禁止され、与えられるイスラム教の死刑を無視する人への教育ガイドを提供している。

同性愛は禁止されたイスラム教で罰すべきであること私達が私達の法的証拠を持って来る前に、私達を論理的に考える許可しなさい: 同性愛は姦通の部門の下で下らないか。 正しくないそれはそれを言うことある 姦通 -定義上では-こうして暗示的に同性愛を含んでいる2つの未婚人間の性交はある、か。 イスラム教は2人の結婚を可能にすること証拠を提供しなければ、私達は姦通の下で論理的にそれを下位範疇と考慮してもいい。

同性愛はように記述されている lewdeness Qurでは」壮大なイマームのAlShanqitiは説明する:

万能の言った、「してはいけないyeを託すあなたの前に託される作成の人々のようなlewdnessを()か」。 (翼部」 RAF: 80). アラーはことを説明した意味される何がlewdnessによってsodomyがある、なぜなら彼はyeの練習のためのその後で言った、「女性への好みの人のあなたの渇望は」。 そして彼は、「世界のall the創造物、意志のyeのアプローチの男性」はの発言と「発言およびあなたの議会の練習の()邪悪によって明白にしたそれをか」。1

Ibn Kathirは注意する:

同性愛が最も悪い憎悪であることが意味される。 それは過去のアラビア人間でそれについての無知がそれらの以上1によって述べられたので、知られなかった。 従って、AlWalidのibnのAbdのAlMalikは人がもう一人の人の上に」。あることができるとアラーの全能の神が私達にLutの人々の物語を述べなかったら、「、私決して考えなかろう言わなかった そしてhadithで誰かをLutの人々の行為を託すことを見つければ報告したIbnの`Abbasによって、それらの言われた予言者(鋸)と喜ばされるかもしれないアラー「殺す両方の関係者を」。 これはsunanの人々によって述べられ、Ibn Habbanによって評価される確実そして他行い。 The Prophet (saws) cursed three times those who commit the act of the people of Lut, and he never cursed anyone for sin three times, except those who do this. He commanded the participants to be killed, for they are not worthy to live among the people because they are corrupt in their actions and sinful in their hearts. Whoever has this likeness, there is nothing within them that is beneficial for creation if they remain. So if Allah saves us from them, our faith and lives will be more righteous. But the curse is to be expelled and made distant. So whoever was expelled and made distant from Allah, His Messenger, His Book and His righteous servants, there is no good in him or in coming near to him. 2

Please ponder upon this insightful quotation of Ibn Kathir; for he does not just inform us about the ugliness of this form of lewdness and its penalty, he also provides the legal and rational explanation for its penalty and tells us why its participant should be exterminated.

Ibn Hazm clearly states:

The act of the people of Lut is from the grievous sins, the most forbidden depravities like eating pork, carrion, or blood, drinking, adultery, and the rest of these disobediences. Anyone who allows it or allows anything from what we have mentioned is a kafir. But the people disagreed regarding the penalty.3

And Sheikh al-Islam Ibn Taimiyyah says:

In regards to sodomy, some scholars say its penalty is like the penalty of adultery, and some say it’s not. The truth is what the companions have agreed upon, that both should be killed, whether they were married or not. Truly the scholars of hadith narrated on behalf of Ibn ‘Abbas, may Allah be pleased with them, that the Prophet (saws) said, “If you find someone committing the acts of the people of Lut, kill both participants.” And Abu Daoud narrated on behalf of Ibn ‘Abbas, may Allah be pleased with them, that if the unmarried is found to be a sodomite he is to be stoned. And ‘Ali ibn Abi Talib, may Allah be pleased with him, narrated something similar.

The companions did not disagree on his killing, but they varied regarding the method. It is narrated on behalf of Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, that he ordered him to be burned. And the others said that he should be killed: Some said that a wall should be pulled down upon him until he died, and some said that he should be imprisoned in the most foul place until death. And some said that he should be taken to the highest building and thrown down, then stoned, as Allah had done to the people of Lut. This is what most of the Salaf said. They said, because Allah had stoned the people of Lut, and He similarly allowed the stoning of the adulterer, so sodomites, whether slaves or freemen, should both be killed. But if one is adult and the other juvenile, the juvenile should punished without killing, and only the adult should be stoned. 4

So we inform the illiterate enemies of Islam that homosexuality is not only prohibited in Islam, but considered one of the most grievous sins as well. The Prophet (P) commanded with killing its participants and cursed them three times, and he never cursed anyone for sin three times, except those who do this. The Prophet’s companions have agreed on killing whosoever do it, whether married or not, free or slave.

Muslim scholars of all times agreed upon condemning sodomy, Ibn Qudama says:

The scholars agree to warn against sodomy. Allah has spoken against it in His Book and the Messenger of Allah spoke against it. Allah Almighty says, “We also (sent) Lut: He said to his people: “Do ye commit lewdness such as no people in creation (ever) committed before you?” (A’raf:80). And the Prophet said, “Allah has cursed those who commit the act of the people of Lut, Allah has cursed those who commit the act of the people of Lut, Allah has cursed those who commit the act of the people of Lut.”5

Abu al-Layth al-Samaqandi says:

Sodomy is forbidden because the Almighty said: “We also (sent) Lut: He said to his people, “Do ye commit lewdness such as no people in creation (ever) committed before you?” (al-A’raf: 80). So He called it lewdness, and Allah Almighty has said: “Come not nigh to acts of lewdness, whether open or secret.” (al-Ana’am: 151)6

Imam al-Nawawi says:

Sodomy is when a man has intercourse with another man. It is forbidden, and it is the worst of sins, for the Almighty said, “Do ye commit lewdness such as no people in creation (ever) committed before you? For ye practice your lusts on men in preference to women: ye are indeed a people transgressing beyond bounds.” (al-A’raf: 80-81)

Here Allah mentions sodomy as sin to show that it’s adultery, because Allah said, “Nor come nigh to adultery, for it is a shameful (deed) and an evil, opening the road (to other evils).” (al-Isra: 32) 7

Abu Ya’la al-Farra’ brings a very valuable note:

Sodomy is worse than adultery; for indeed female private can be lawful under marriage contract. 8

But certainly, a male private can never be lawful under any condition!

Due to the agreed-upon consensus of Muslim scholars based upon the Qur’an, the Prophetic Sunnah and agreement of Prophet’s companions and all subsequent generations, prohibition of homosexuality is regarded one of the necessarily known facts of Islam and whosoever denies this prohibition is considered a kafir. Little else can be said for the illiteracy of the worshippers of a half-naked, Roman criminal swinging from a cross, whose ignorance in such an intricate Islamic matter is as blinding as the sun.

May Allah bless all those who follow His Path and guide those who do not.

  1. al-Shanqiti, Adwa’ al-Bayan, 2/232) [back]
  2. Ibn Kathir, al-Bidayah wa al-Nihayah, 9/46 [back]
  3. Ibn Hazm, al-Muhalla, 13/388 [back]
  4. Ibn Taimiyyah, al-Fatawa al-Kubra, 28/317 [back]
  5. Ibn Qudama al-Maqdisi, al-Mughni, 8/116 [back]
  6. al-Samarqandi, al-Muhathab, 2/347 [back]
  7. al-Nawawi, al-Mujmou’, 21/237 [back]
  8. al-Farra’, al-Masa’il al-Fiqhiyyah, 2/320 [back]

One Response to “The Consensus on Homosexuality and The Illiteracy of Christian Polemicists”

  1. umyacub said on 28 October 2007:

    Salam Aleikum, hermanos he leido sus comentarios que Inshala nos orienten hacia los mejores propositos,durante la lectura he notado que parece ser la traduccion de algun otro idioma, me gustaria ponerme a las ordenes para hacer la revision de la traducion al español ya que existen algunos errores de sintaxis que no permiten una lectura mas clara.
    Salam Alelikum ua rahamatullah ua barkatuh
    umyacub@yahoo.es

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.